What happens when a valuer gets it wrong?

When selecting an insurance valuer every three years, price is naturally a key deciding factor for sectional title trustees. But, what about accuracy and track record?
The unfortunate reality is that an insurance valuation is susceptible to human error as it relies on the valuer’s personal experience and judgment.

How to screen an insurance valuer
Trustees have a fiduciary duty to ensure that the body corporate is adequately insured; therefore, prospective valuers must be thoroughly vetted before they are appointed. Aside from comparing prices, it is equally important to check the valuer’s sectional title experience and track record.

Here are a few questions you need to ask prospective valuers:
1. Is the valuer certified by the SA Council for the Property Valuers Profession (SACPVP)?
2. How many years has the valuer been active in the sectional title industry?
3. How many complexes has the valuer assessed over the past year?
4. Does the valuer hold professional indemnity insurance and how much?

What happens if the valuer makes a mistake?
If a body corporate finds themselves under-insured at claim stage as a result of an inaccurate valuation, the trustees can rely on the valuer’s professional indemnity insurance to cover the shortfall. That is, IF the valuer they selected has sufficient professional indemnity insurance (many do not!).

How much professional indemnity insurance is needed?
Most valuers are insured for any amount ranging from R1 million to R10 million – but this is hardly enough! It is recommended that the valuer holds at least 10% of the assessed insurance value and no less than R20 million. (Mirfin holds R45 million professional indemnity insurance).

Without sufficient professional indemnity insurance, the valuer will be unable to cover the shortfall and the affected body corporate members will hold the trustees financially responsible in their personal capacity. For a sectional title scheme, this amount can amount to millions of rands.

As a last resort, the trustees then try to claim the shortfall from their trustee indemnity insurance but be aware that the insurer may reject the claim based on gross negligence if they find that the valuer screening process was insufficient or lacking in its entirety.

For reasons stated above, it is vital for trustees to take the valuer selection process more seriously than just looking at the initial quotation to conduct the valuation. The last thing you want is to be held liable for millions because you tried to save the body corporate a few hundred rand.

Make sure that the valuation company you select is sufficiently covered in the case of a claim to protect yourself as well as experienced enough to alleviate the likelihood of errors.

Get an instant quotation for your next insurance valuation here.



What happens when a valuer gets it wrong?


How we assess a building's replacement cost


Much like insurance, having your building professionally valued may feel like a grudge purchase. However, when your claims are processed in record time and the entire amount claimed is paid out, you will be very happy you did!

How to determine a building's insurance value


The true price of a cheap insurance valuation


Why you don't need three comparative quotes for your next valuation


Why the schedule of replacement values is important


Retaining walls - the risk explained (Part 1)


Retaining walls - the risk explained (Part 2)


Checklist for Insurance Valuations


Attention: Short-Term Insurance Brokers


Experience has taught us that approximately two thirds of all residential homes and contents are underinsured by between 20 - 50%. The reality is that very few property owners are correctly covered.

Contents valuation: Moveable Assets Registry (Part 2)


Market value and replacement cost: Not the same thing!


Contents Valuations: Moveable Asset Registry (Part 1)


How the lack of an insurance valuation leads to averaging


Without an updated insurance valuation, you could find yourself being underinsured and facing averaging by your insurer. As a trustee, you have a fiduciary duty to obtain an updated insurance valuation to ensure adequate insurance cover.

How to object to your municipal property valuation


Escalation of Buildings Insurance


When an insurance policy is due for renewal, many financial advisors will recommend a fixed annual escalation rate of 10%, sometimes even 15%. Does this reflect reality? What if the original sum insured was incorrect to begin with?

How to insure owner-installed upgrades in sectional title units


Why it is wrong to insure the market value of your house


How to budget for a valuation and compare quotations


With the Sectional Title Schemes Management (STSM) Act activated in October 2016, sectional title owners need to have insurance valuations done every 3 years. We look at how to go budget for this expense and the factors one must keep in mind when selecting a valuer. The key words are: professional indemnity insurance.



Trustee liability in the event of underinsurance


What the sectional title law says about valuations


In this blog we highlight the key information for bodies corporate in the Sectional Title Schemes Management Act (STSM) No. 8 of 2011, including what a sectional title valuation ideally should entail.

10-Year Maintenance Plans for Sectional Title Schemes: What you need to know.


Capetonians beware: Rates increase approaching!


Municipal rates in Johannesburg – have you checked your property values?


Common customer complaints


This blog comprises a number of typical customer complaints that we deal with on a regular basis. Along with these complaints, we include our responses for easy reference and insight into common insurance valuation matters.